Over 50% of senior MES candidates receive counteroffers; over 80% who accept one leave within 12 months anyway.
Definition
A counteroffer is when a candidate's current employer responds to their resignation with improved terms, typically a salary increase, promotion, or new responsibilities, in an attempt to retain them. Counteroffer rates in senior technical roles have increased significantly since 2021, with some reports suggesting 50 to 60 per cent of candidates receive one.
What this means when you're hiring
In ten years of MES recruitment, counteroffers are my single biggest source of late-stage fallouts. When the talent pool is narrow and specialist knowledge is hard to replace, companies panic when a key person resigns and throw money at the problem. The research is consistent: over 80 per cent of candidates who accept a counteroffer leave within 12 months anyway. The underlying reasons for wanting to leave don't disappear because the salary went up by 15 per cent. I qualify every candidate on this explicitly at second stage; a candidate who hasn't thought through the counteroffer scenario is a higher attrition risk at offer stage.
Where candidates get this wrong
Hiring managers often think a candidate accepting a counteroffer means they were never genuinely committed to the move. That's too simplistic. Counteroffers exploit the psychological discomfort of change at a moment of maximum uncertainty. The better question is whether the candidate's motivations for moving were strong enough to survive that pressure, and that's what good qualification reveals early in the process.
How expectations change by level
Counteroffers are most common at senior specialist level where knowledge is concentrated and replacement costs are high. A seasoned PAS-X Project Manager who's just delivered a major site rollout is far more likely to receive an aggressive counteroffer than a junior MES analyst. At C-suite level, the counteroffer risk drops slightly because the decision to leave is usually more strategic and less salary-driven.
Related Roles
Ready to hire in MES or Industry 4.0?
We specialise exclusively in manufacturing software and digital transformation leadership. 250+ critical hires delivered.